New York on My Mind

I’m a big fan of New York wines. Riesling from the Finger Lakes seems
to get better every year, especially as winemakers continue to carve
out a distinctive style that speaks of the region’s terroir. Are they
particularly German? Well, maybe not, though some definitely have that
mineral oil quality (many wine lovers call it petrol or diesel, but I
think mineral oil seems more positive a reference). The ones that send
me over the top when I taste them have bracing acidity and an almost
unbearable lightness of being, an ephemeral characteristic that leaves
flavors flitting across your palate with surprising complexity, even if
the initial impression may not carry depth. If I had to point to a
German region and insist on making the comparison, I’d say Finger Lakes
Rieslings (at least the ones that excite me the most) remind me of the
delicate wines from the Mittelrhein, which admittedly is not Germany’s
most revered wine region. (Though I love that delicacy!) So perhaps it’s
best just to say that New York is carving out its own identity with the

Of course, I have a soft spot for Seneca Lake, which is the middle finger. (Ba-da-boom!)

of my favorites? Hermann J. Wiemer and Dr. Konstantin Frank are the
most classic. The ones that I find especially enticing come from Fox
Run, Anthony Road and Red Newt. Chateau Lafayette Reneau had a wonderful
Riesling that won Best in Show at the Atlantic Seaboard Wine
Competition once, and at this year’s judging I flipped for what turned
out to be the 2009 Dry Riesling from Glenora.

New York is not
limited to the Finger Lakes, of course. Long Island is making some
delicious reds, and this region is also establishing its own style and
character – the better wineries are no longer trying to make Pomerol,
they’re just happy making the best damn Long Island merlot they can.

more and more New York wines are now reaching the D.C. area market,
which means they are making enough to distribute wines outside the
state. This was the topic of my Washington Post
column last week. This column was particularly gratifying because it
engendered considerably more response than I usually get, through
e-mails and phone calls. Most of them said something like, “Nice column,
but you didn’t mention my favorite … ” That means readers are aware
of New York wines and looking out for them, whether on their travels up
north or now on their local retail shelves.

For more information about New York’s wineries, go to, the website of the New York Wine & Grape Foundation, or to Lenn Thompson’s New York Cork Report. Don’t forget Regional Wine Week coming up Oct. 10-16 on!

This entry was posted in Competitions,, Eastern US, Germany, Local Wine, New York, Regional Wine Week, Riesling, Terroir, Washington Post, Web/Tech, Weblogs, Wine, writers and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Join the Discussion!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s